CIVICUS discusses Spain’s protests over its housing crisis with Oriol Erausquin, a lecturer in sociology at the Complutense University of Madrid and a digital activist who has taken part in demonstrations and sit-ins in the capital.

Spain will hold a snap election on 29 November. Prime Minister Pedro Sánchez called the election on 5 October, after parliament rejected two decrees that would have extended tenancy agreements and suspended evictions of vulnerable people. The government brought forward the decrees in response to the protests sparked by the eviction of María del Carmen Abascal, known as Maricarmen, in Madrid on 23 September. Her death two weeks later placed housing at the centre of the campaign.

Why did Maricarmen’s case mobilise so many people?

The enormous outrage generated by the case stemmed from the fact that it brought together several injustices. At the age of 87, Maricarmen faced eviction from the home she had lived in since she was 17 and where she wanted to spend the rest of her life. She had a ‘renta antigua’ tenancy agreement, a type of low-cost, open-ended tenancy dating from before 1985. It had been signed by her father in 1956, at the height of the Franco regime, when women were not permitted to sign such contracts. Upon his death, the tenancy passed to her mother, and when her mother died in 2005, it passed to Maricarmen.

A law introduced by the Spanish Socialist Workers’ Party (PSOE) limited the number of times an old-style tenancy agreement could be inherited, but for years Maricarmen was able to remain in her home. Everything changed when a property development company bought the building and used that second inheritance to ask the courts to terminate the tenancy agreement. Had her mother been able to sign it alongside her father, Maricarmen would have retained the original terms.

To allow her to stay, the company demanded she sign a new tenancy agreement for €1,650 (approx. US$1,800) a month, more than triple the €500 (approx. US$550) she had been paying. It was an extreme case, illustrating how regulations, property speculation and historical inequalities could force an elderly woman out of her home.

Many people endure eviction in silence, but Maricarmen decided to stand up to it and make it public. For years, the Tenants’ Union stood by her, raised awareness of her situation and fought alongside her to prevent her eviction. Public pressure halted three attempts, and before the fourth, hundreds of people spent the night outside her home. The images of an 87-year-old woman being carried out on a stretcher finally sparked widespread outrage. Her case demonstrated that collective action brings evictions out of isolation and invisibility, and that organising alongside those affected can make a difference.

Why is it so difficult to access housing in Spain?

It’s a problem that’s common to many countries and stems, in part, from a shift in the global economy. As productive investments yield lower returns, more and more capital is channelled into rent-seeking, a model that derives profits from ownership of housing and land without generating new wealth or productive activity.

As a result, housing is no longer treated as a basic right but as an object of speculation. It’s as if people were speculating on the price of water, something we all need to survive. Consequently, many people find themselves homeless or are forced to spend more than half their wages on rent.

In Spain, the situation is exacerbated by the rise in properties used for tourist lets on platforms such as Airbnb and the influx of international investment funds buying up properties for speculative purposes. Housing has become a business that prioritises profit over the needs of those seeking a place to live.

How is the housing movement organised and what strategies have proved successful?

The movement brings together organisations that stop evictions, advise people suffering abuse from their landlords and, in some cases, occupy empty properties to house vulnerable families.

Tenants’ unions are experimenting with new forms of organisation and mobilisation. In Madrid, teams from the Tenants’ Union go door to door in blocks of flats to encourage residents to organise themselves. These unions have also developed an effective communication strategy, with a strong presence on media and social media, and have succeeded in turning individual cases into collective causes.

In Barcelona,the Sindicat de Llogateres turned Casa Orsola into a symbol of the fight against property speculation. An investment fund bought the building and, according to the union’s allegations, wanted to convert the flats into short-term lettings. Under the slogan ‘Today it’s Josep, but tomorrow it could be you’, the union framed the eviction of one of the residents as a threat to everyone else. Over a thousand people blocked the entrance to the building and thwarted two attempts at eviction. Public pressure led the City Council to purchase the building, ensuring tenants could stay.

I believe one of the movement’s main strengths is that it is not afraid to experiment, assess what works and learn from its mistakes. That flexibility has been key to achieving victories.

How have the authorities responded to the protests?

Faced with pressure from the protests, the PSOE government brought before parliament two housing decrees that had been gathering dust for months. Parliament rejected them, and as the housing crisis was already at the centre of public debate, Pedro Sánchez called a general election. Since then, the PSOE has sought to incorporate housing demands into its electoral strategy, aware the issue could work in its favour against the right and far right.

At the same time, as the protests grew, so did police repression. The police forcibly cleared tent camps in Puerta del Sol, Madrid’s central square, and in Seville. During the strike on 11 November, they cracked down on picket lines going round shops and workplaces to recruit people to the strike, and used batons, pepper spray and rubber bullets against a major peaceful demonstration in Madrid’s Plaza de España.

What would the rejected decrees have changed and why were they blocked?

The decrees could have alleviated some of the main difficulties faced by tenants. They would have protected vulnerable households with no alternative accommodation from eviction, capped rent increases and made it easier to renew tenancy agreements. They aimed to curb the purchase of properties for speculative purposes and prevent landlords resorting to tourist or seasonal tenancies to circumvent the minimum tenancy period and rent caps.

Behind the blocking of the decrees lie economic and class interests. A large part of the establishment, across the political spectrum, defends the rentier model, and many politicians have links to landlords, investment funds and other property interests.

After eight years in power, Sánchez’s government has failed to introduce legislation to resolve the housing crisis, and housing continues to be treated as just another commodity on the market. It has preferred to subsidise landlords rather than tackle the root of the problem. Meanwhile, the working class is paying ever-higher rents and has far less influence over political decisions than landlords.

What will civil society demand of the next government?

Civil society is calling for ambitious and decisive measures to transform the housing market, rather than half-hearted solutions that merely alleviate the crisis temporarily. Among its key demands are capping rent prices, preventing investment funds speculating on housing and reclaiming for public use properties owned by these funds and illegal tourist flats.

The next government should expand the public housing stock by building new homes and incorporating reclaimed properties. This stock should grow on an ongoing basis and remain outside the speculative market, so public housing does not end up being sold off and converted into private rentals.

CIVICUS interviews a wide range of civil society activists, experts and leaders to gather diverse perspectives on civil society action and current issues for publication on its CIVICUS Lens platform. The views expressed in interviews are the interviewees’ and do not necessarily reflect those of CIVICUS. Publication does not imply endorsement of interviewees or the organisations they represent.