GUATEMALA: ‘Protest and freedom of expression are not crimes’
CIVICUS discusses the criminalisation of protest in Guatemala with Nanci Sinto, an Indigenous Kaqchikel Maya woman dedicated to defending the civic and political rights of young people, protecting Indigenous women and preserving historical memory.
Since 2 September, Nanci has been on trial for her participation in protests in 2020. A judge dismissed the case in 2022, but the Attorney General’s Office, Congress and the Public Prosecutor’s Office appealed and succeeded in reopening the case. The court admitted 50 pieces of evidence from the prosecution but just one from the defence. Human rights organisations warn that Guatemala’s criminal justice system is being used to punish protest.
What are you accused of and how is the trial progressing?
I am accused of damaging national property for allegedly spray-painting the facade of Congress during protests against the budget in November 2020. My defence team has highlighted breaches of due process and the right to a defence, such as the rejection of evidence deemed crucial, a lack of equality of arms vis-à-vis the Public Prosecutor’s Office, and other judicial irregularities.
During the oral and public trial, which is ongoing, evidence has emerged that casts doubt on the charges. Even the experts of the Public Prosecutor’s Office acknowledged that the paint was removed without damaging the structure of the Congress building. The origin of the images presented as evidence and the chain of custody have also been called into question. We continue to face the proceedings with the conviction that protest and freedom of expression are not crimes.
Why do you think your case was reopened and what has become of the investigation into the police assault you suffered?
The reopening of the case is part of a strategy of persecution. It seeks to instil fear and exploit criminal law to demobilise Indigenous communities, women and young people. It is a way of punishing those of us who take dissenting stances, denounce injustices and challenge the impunity that prevails in Guatemala.
In contrast, the investigation into the National Civil Police officers who assaulted me during the protest on 21 November 2020 is making no progress. The judge who initially heard my case ordered an investigation into possible abuse of authority, but so far there has been no substantial progress and no one has been held to account. The state has been diligent in pursuing me criminally, but not in investigating the violence perpetrated by its own officers. This inequality, compounded by institutional racism, shows how the justice system operates. The victim ends up being treated as the perpetrator.
What does your case reveal about the criminalisation of protest and its effects?
My case highlights a pattern of criminalisation of protest and of political violence that seeks to punish those of us who challenge those in power. It also reflects the colonial, patriarchal and racist structures of a state that has historically denied Indigenous peoples their status as political subjects and their right to challenge and transform power relations. However, those in power have not succeeded, nor will they succeed, in preventing Indigenous peoples from continuing to challenge these structures.
In Guatemala, political violence against women is still not specifically and comprehensively classified as a criminal offence. That is why I consider it important to name it and highlight it in my case. Intimidation, judicial persecution and violence against those of us who protest also seek to limit our political rights, including freedoms of assembly, association and expression.
These practices generate fear, self-censorship and demobilisation, particularly amongst Maya women, who have historically been relegated to domestic work rather than being recognised as political participants. But they also remind us of the importance of defending our right to protest and participate in Guatemala’s political life.
How has Guatemalan civil society supported you?
We have received various expressions of solidarity and resistance. Civil society organisations have spoken out through press conferences, public actions, social media posts and statements. They have attended the hearings and provided psychosocial support and ad hoc financial assistance to cover health and security needs.
This coordination has been vital in breaking the isolation that criminalisation seeks to create and in reminding us we are not alone. Community media have also helped counter the smear campaigns against me.
What international support do you need?
At this stage, it is important that international human rights organisations monitor and accompany the process and speak out publicly to demand guarantees of justice and denounce the trial’s irregularities and malicious delays.
We also need ad hoc financial support to meet the needs that arise during the process. These cases are long and gruelling, and support often dries up before they are over. That is why it is essential that international solidarity and support are sustained over the long term.
CIVICUS interviews a wide range of civil society activists, experts and leaders to gather diverse perspectives on civil society action and current issues for publication on its CIVICUS Lens platform. The views expressed in interviews are the interviewees’ and do not necessarily reflect those of CIVICUS. Publication does not imply endorsement of interviewees or the organisations they represent.