Cambodia’s young environmental activists pay a heavy price
Cambodian authorities recently handed down lengthy prison sentences to 10 young activists from the Mother Nature civil society group in retaliation for their work defending the environment. This is part of a pattern in Cambodia, where the state routinely suppresses legitimate dissent. It’s particularly risky for civil society to oppose the exploitation of natural resources and stand up to the powerful economic interests involved. With tight state control over civil society and the media, Cambodian civil society faces an uphill challenge in urging the government to protect rights. Pressure should come from Cambodia’s international partners.
It’s risky to try to protect the environment in authoritarian Cambodia. In July, 10 young activists from the Mother Nature environmental group were given long jail sentences. Two were sentenced to eight years under the Criminal Code on charges of plotting and insulting the king. Another seven were sentenced to six years for plotting, while one, a Spanish national banned from entering Cambodia, was sentenced in absentia.
Four of the activists were then violently dragged away from a peaceful sit-in they’d joined outside the court building. The five who’ve so far been jailed have been split up and sent to separate prisons, some far away from their families. They now face the prospect of spending precious years of their youth locked away.
This is the latest in a long line of state attacks on Mother Nature activists, which have included threats and harassment alongside criminalisation. Mother Nature is being punished for its work to try to protect natural resources, prevent water pollution and stop illegal logging and sand mining.
The more you repress us, the more resolute our fight to protect #Cambodia 's nature will be.
— Mother Nature Cambodia (@CambodiaMother) July 3, 2024
The more you to try to break our spirit, the stronger we will be.
Ratha, Kunthea, Daravuth, Akeo and Leanghy: We love you & respect your immense sacrifices. #FreetheMotherNature5 pic.twitter.com/2CoMwyHpjw
An autocratic regime
Cambodia’s de facto one-party regime tolerates little criticism. Its former prime minister, Hun Sen, was one of the world’s longest-serving leaders, ruling the country from 1985 until 2023, when he handed over to his son, Hun Manet. This came shortly after a non-competitive election where the only credible opposition party was banned. It was the same story with the previous election in 2018. This suppression of democracy required a crackdown on dissenting voices, targeting civil society as well as the political opposition.
The authorities have weaponised the legal system. They use highly politicised courts to detain civil society activists and opposition politicians for long spells before subjecting them to grossly unfair trials. Campaigners for environmental rights, labour rights and social justice are frequently charged with vaguely defined offences under the Criminal Code such as plotting and incitement. Last year, for example, nine trade unionists were convicted of incitement after going on strike to demand better pay and conditions for casino workers, and their leader was jailed.
On top of this, in 2015 the government introduced the restrictive Law on Associations and Non-Governmental Organisations (LANGO), which requires civil society organisations to submit financial records and annual reports, giving the state broad powers to refuse registration or deregister organisations. In 2023, Hun Sen threatened to dissolve organisations if they failed to submit documents.
The state also closely controls the media. People close to the ruling family run the four main media groups and so they mostly follow the government line. Independent media outlets are severely restricted. Last year the authorities shut down one of the last remaining independent platforms, Voice of Democracy, after it published an article on Hun Manet. Journalists face harassment, surveillance and violence. Self-censorship means topics such as corruption and environmental concerns remain largely uncovered.
This extensive political control is closely entwined with economic power. The ruling family and its inner circle are connected to an array of economic projects that exploit environmental resources. Landgrabs by state officials are common. These means land and Indigenous people’s rights activists are among those targeted.
In 2023, courts sentenced 10 land activists to a year in jail in response to their activism against land grabbing for a sugar plantation. That same year, three people from the Coalition of Cambodian Farmer Community, a farmers’ rights group, were charged with incitement and plotting. In 2022, a court sentenced five Indigenous forest activists to five to six years in prison for trying to defend their land from illegal logging; fortunately the five had charges dropped on appeal. The authorities have also used the LANGO to prevent unregistered community groups taking part in anti-logging patrols.
The activity that saw the Mother Nature activists charged with plotting involved documenting the flow of waste into a river close to the royal palace in the capital, Phnom Pen. It’s far from the first time the group’s environmental action has earned the state’s ire. The government feels threatened by the fact that Mother Nature’s activism resonates with many young people.
Unfortunately, in Cambodia, the more effective your activism, the more likely you are to be targeted by a government that doesn’t see dissent as legitimate and won’t accept those who contradict it or cause it to lose face.
Three of the group’s activists were convicted on incitement charges in 2022 after organising a protest march to the prime minister’s residence to protest against the filling in of a lake for a construction project. In 2023, Mother Nature delivered a petition urging the government to stop granting land to private companies in Kirirom National Park; there’s evidence of licences going to people connected to ruling party politicians. In response, the Ministry of Environment said Mother Nature was an illegal organisation that had been dissolved, that it had committed ‘illegal acts’ and that its actions were ‘against the interests of Cambodian civil society’.
Last September, three Mother Nature representatives serving suspended sentences were denied permission to travel to Sweden to receive the Right Livelihood Award – a prize recognising activism for a just, peaceful and sustainable world.
Media also get in trouble if they report on the sensitive issue of land exploitation. In 2023, the authorities revoked the licences of three media companies for publishing reports on a senior official’s involvement in land fraud. In 2022, two teams of reporters covering a deforestation operation were violently arrested.
Voices from the frontline
Naly Pilorge is Outreach Director of the Cambodian League for the Promotion and Defence of Human Rights
Mother Nature focuses on protecting Cambodia’s remaining natural resources. Activists use direct action to raise awareness and pressure the authorities to protect the country’s national parks, forests and islands. It has been very effective in drawing public attention to important environmental issues, and has even had some success in getting the government to reverse some of its more outrageous concessions and giveaways to private interests.
In the process, it has made powerful enemies within the state. Unfortunately, in Cambodia, the more effective your activism, the more likely you are to be targeted by a government that doesn’t see dissent as legitimate and won’t accept those who contradict it or cause it to lose face. That’s why the 10 activists were charged with the outrageous crime of conspiracy against the state and given such disproportionate sentences – six to eight years in prison for their peaceful activism. These sentences should serve as a sobering reminder and deter others from doing the same.
In Cambodia, people’s ability to exercise their fundamental civic freedoms of association, expression and peaceful assembly depends on the whims of the government, which sometimes allows a bit more space but often heavily restricts it. It usually does this by routinely misusing criminal legislation enacted for other purposes to undermine and weaken civil society and criminalise human rights defenders, trade unionists, youth activists, journalists and other critical voices.
If activists can get long prison sentences for testing polluted river water, advocating against deforestation or calling for the preservation of the capital’s remaining lakes, it means any meaningful activism entails immense personal risk.
So, this isn’t just about Mother Nature or even about environmental activism. All human rights defenders, including environmental activists, face an impossible situation as repression intensifies.
Fortunately, while harsh punishments for peaceful environmental activism may have a short-term chilling effect, in the long term, repression is doomed to fail. The courage of the young activists targeted will also inspire a new generation of young human rights defenders.
To help build greater respect for human rights and democratic freedoms in our country, we need everyone to stop pretending things are normal in Cambodia. Too many people are wilfully ignoring the fact that an already bad situation has deteriorated sharply over the past year. Cambodian people need new strategies, new tactics and meaningful responses from the institutions that claim to be our international partners.
This is an edited extract of our conversation with Naly. Read the full interview here.
Regional challenges
Repression of environmental activism isn’t limited to Cambodia. In neighbouring Vietnam, the one-party communist state is also cracking down on climate and environmental activists, who previously enjoyed some degree of freedom compared to the rest of civil society. But that’s no longer the case, in part because, as in Cambodia, climate and environmental activism is increasingly shining a light on the environmentally destructive economic practices of authoritarian leaders.
Cambodia’s creeping use of the charge of insulting the king to stifle legitimate dissent also echoes a tactic frequently used across the border in Thailand, where the authorities have jailed several people for violating an archaic lèse majesté law that criminalises any criticism of the king. Thailand, which was under military rule and where the army still plays a major role in government, has in recent years increasingly used this law against young people calling for democracy and curbs on royal influence. Other repressive states have followed its lead – including Cambodia, where the law on insulting the king was introduced when the crackdown was well underway in 2018.
Cambodia provides ample evidence of how the denial of democracy and the repression that comes with it enable extractive and exploitative policies that also adversely affect people’s lives and rights. The solution to protect the environment and prevent runaway climate change is less repression, more democracy and a more enabled civil society.
Cambodia’s international partners should emphasise this in their dealings with the state. They should press the authorities to release the jailed Mother Nature activists. They should be seen as part of the solution, not the problem. They should spend the coming years helping make their country a better place, not rotting in prison.
OUR CALLS FOR ACTION
-
The government of Cambodia must overturn the convictions of the Mother Nature activists and immediately and unconditionally release them.
-
The government must end the use of repressive laws to criminalise activists and repeal all provisions in the Criminal Code that restrict the exercise of fundamental freedoms.
-
The international community must raise concerns with the Cambodian government about the closure of civic space, including for environmental activism.
For interviews or more information, please contact research@civicus.org
Cover photo by Tang Chhin Sothy/AFP via Getty Images