Brazil: a comeback from the streets and social media
Fear of losing hard-won rights fed a wave of online and street mobilisation, much of it by young people, and brought millions of abstainers back to the polls to re-elect Lula da Silva as Brazil’s president on 25 October. The campaign was fought on an uneven field, with complaints about social media platforms, disinformation and election-day transport failures. Lula’s opponent Flávio Bolsonaro refused to concede and fled to the USA. Lula will, however, face a Congress in which his rival’s party is the biggest force. His victory keeps a far-right project for Brazil’s institutions and the Amazon out of the presidency, but the movement behind it retains formidable influence.
Three weeks after a first-round defeat, 80-year-old President Lula da Silva was re-elected with 51.79 per cent of the valid vote on 25 October. It was the first such comeback since Brazil’s return to democracy.
A first-round shock
Although most polls gave Lula, of the Workers’ Party (PT), a slight lead, the 4 October first round went to Flávio Bolsonaro, son of former president Jair Bolsonaro. Running for the Liberal Party (PL), he took 47.03 per cent against Lula’s 45.16 per cent. The rest of the vote went to minor and mostly conservative candidates.
Lula went into the race weighed down by public concerns about household debt, inflation and crime, which many voters ranked as their top issue. A banking scandal that implicated figures across the political spectrum kept corruption in the headlines. Abstention also hurt him. Just over 21 per cent of the electorate stayed home for the first round, the highest figure since 1998, and his margins in the Northeast were no longer enough to give him a decisive win.
But coming second possibly saved Lula. Had he finished first, even narrowly, his campaign would have had every reason to stay the same, and the complacency that kept many of his voters at home on 4 October could have cost him the runoff. Defeat forced a rethink and made a Bolsonaro restoration feel real. People who’d stayed at home, or voted for Lula without enthusiasm, suddenly faced the prospect of losing social welfare payments, public education funding, labour protections and the freedom to protest and organise. They also feared Jair Bolsonaro and his fellow plotters, convicted of trying to overturn the 2022 election, would be granted an amnesty.
Winning the first round turned out to be a trap for Flávio Bolsonaro. In the days that followed, he behaved as if the presidency were already his. He kept saying he’d free his father, serving a 27-year sentence imposed by the Supreme Court for plotting a coup. He said the what he called the right’s new congressional majority would allow him to ‘change the constitution’ and ‘redemocratise’ Brazil. He didn’t say exactly what he meant, but the PL’s agenda included using the Senate to remove Supreme Court justices, and the pledge sounded like a threat to the court that convicted his father. The backlash was strong enough that the next day he had to explain he planned relatively minor changes. That same day, however, he insisted the Lula era was over and his family would ‘govern for decades’.
The Bolsonaro name has become a political brand. On 4 October, four members of the family won Congress seats, including former first lady Michelle Bolsonaro and one of Flávio’s brothers, Carlos. Another brother, Eduardo, who’s lived in the USA since early 2025 and has since lost his seat in Congress, lobbied the Trump administration to impose sanctions and tariffs on Lula’s Brazil. Many saw a political dynasty in the making and wanted to stop it.
Mobilisation from below
Within days of the first round, the National Union of Students (UNE) was marching in Goiânia, Porto Alegre, Rio de Janeiro and Salvador and calling protests in at least 16 states and the Federal District. Students declared themselves in permanent mobilisation, tying their support for Lula to demands such as more money for public education and the end of the six-day working week. By the campaign’s final week, rallies had reached 11 state capitals and many smaller cities.
Streets and social media connected. Students and everyday people led on both, and Lula’s campaign followed. Shaken by the first-round result, it overhauled its communications. Lula swapped the stage for mass marches, speaking to crowds from a truck. On 7 October, he met over 100 young legislators and other elected officials, and left-wing influencers in Brasília, and then began recording selfie-style videos in the direct language of social media. Online, the left showed a command of campaigning that had been the far right’s territory since Jair Bolsonaro’s rise in 2018. Lula ally and federal deputy André Janones turned his Exército do Lula WhatsApp channel into a hub with over 10 million subscribers, sharing coordinated hashtags and instructions. Digital influencers and many others added their own content.
People mobilised in the face of serious obstacles. Lula’s campaign accused Meta, which owns Facebook, Instagram and WhatsApp, of limiting the reach of the campaign’s posts, and complained that its AI tool wouldn’t produce images of Lula but would for his rival. On 15 October, the Superior Electoral Court (TSE) ordered Meta to treat the two campaigns equally, including in AI image requests, or face daily fines. Meta admitted technical problems but denied taking sides.
As disinformation surged between rounds, the TSE also came under suspicion. According to an analysis by the Nexo news site, the TSE’s president, Kassio Nunes Marques, a Supreme Court justice appointed by Jair Bolsonaro, ruled in favour of Lula’s campaign on 17 per cent of its injunction requests and in favour of Flávio Bolsonaro’s on 69 per cent.
Civil society pushed back. On 19 October, hundreds of activists, social movements and organisations, including digital rights groups and Greenpeace Brasil, protested outside Meta’s offices in São Paulo under the slogan ‘Meta, não se meta’ (‘Meta, don’t meddle’). Over 100 organisations signed an open letter coordinated by the digital rights group CTRL+Z. It urged Brazil’s electoral authorities and international human rights bodies to act against interference by big tech companies and demanded transparency and regulation.
Closing the gap
Between rounds, Lula gained 10.4 million votes against Flávio Bolsonaro’s 3.7 million. Abstention fell to 19.2 per cent, bringing around three million more people to the polls. Minas Gerais, the second most populous state, swung from Flávio Bolsonaro to Lula.
Older voters made a difference. Voting is optional for Brazilians over 70, and over-70s made up around 40 per cent of additional runoff voters. Ageism aimed at Lula helped bring them out. Flávio Bolsonaro’s campaign treated Lula’s age as a weakness, and the tactic backfired in the final TV debate on 23 October, when Flávio Bolsonaro also mocked Lula for having lost a finger on the job as a young metalworker and had to apologise on air.
Incumbency helped too, with higher social welfare payments starting in October. Flávio Bolsonaro, meanwhile, hit a ceiling. A poll published on 21 October found 52 per cent of voters would never vote for him, against 47 per cent who wouldn’t back Lula.
The comeback also won voters from well outside Lula’s camp. Many centre-right Brazilians wanted an alternative to Lula, but not the kind the Bolsonaros offer. Some may have reasoned that a Lula win would clear the way for a more moderate right in 2030, when Lula can’t run again, with São Paulo governor Tarcísio de Freitas its natural candidate. In São Paulo, voting for Lula for president but Tarcísio for governor was common enough to earn a nickname, the Tarlula effect.
Lula made the move easier. The firebrand trade unionist who first ran for president in 1989 has increasingly moved towards the centre and in 2022 picked Geraldo Alckmin, a centre-right former São Paulo governor, as his running mate. After the first round, Alckmin, now vice-president and again on the ticket, led the effort to win over moderate and middle-class voters.
Two projects for Brazil
The contest is often described as polarised, suggesting two extremes pulling apart. But Brazil’s polarisation is asymmetric. A centre-left president with a centre-right running mate faced a far-right movement that has absorbed much of the mainstream right and counts Argentina’s President Javier Milei and Israel’s Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu among its international backers. Lula drew on the PT and its allies, but above all on organised civil society and social movements, including the student movement and trade unions.
Each side has a distinct set of core voters. Lula’s strongest support comes from the Northeast, women, lower-income voters, Catholics and people over 60; Flávio Bolsonaro’s from the South and Southeast, men and evangelical Christians. Their voters live in largely separate information ecosystems, and the far right has spent years teaching its supporters that a victory for the left can only result from fraud. That narrative culminated in the 8 January 2023 attack on federal institutions in Brasília and the coup plot that put Jair Bolsonaro behind bars.
Flávio Bolsonaro tried to present himself as a softer version of his father, calling himself the ‘vaccinated Bolsonaro’, a reference to the former president’s refusal to be jabbed against COVID-19. But the distancing went only so far, as he insisted his father had ‘done his best’ during the pandemic, when Brazil recorded the second-highest death toll in the world behind the USA.
On top of pledging constitutional changes widely seen as targeting the Supreme Court and a blanket amnesty for those convicted for the attempted coup, Flávio’s programme kept the core of his father’s project intact. His security plan proposed classifying criminal groups as narcoterrorist organisations, building maximum-security prisons modelled on those of El Salvador and partnering with the Trump administration against organised crime. On the economy, he offered spending cuts amounting to around 1.5 per cent of GDP, including by abolishing at least 10 ministries, along with tax cuts and a debt ceiling.
Lula ran on his record, including the reduction of the working week from 44 to 40 hours without a loss in pay, which Congress approved ahead of the runoff, and on a social agenda that included income tax exemption for lower earners, a higher minimum wage, free public transport and a new public security ministry.
Climate not on the ballot
To the frustration of civil society, climate barely featured in the campaign, even as fires spread across the Amazon and El Niño threatened more fires in the North and floods in the South. Brazil is still recovering from the record Amazon drought and the 2024 floods in Rio Grande do Sul, which killed over 180 people.
However, the candidates’ records and programmes pointed in very different directions. Under Lula, Amazon deforestation fell to its lowest annual level since records began in 1988, and he has committed to net zero deforestation by 2030. His programme recognised that climate change is an emergency. But Lula has also championed oil exploration at the mouth of the Amazon River, which would threaten a highly sensitive ecosystem, and pledged to strengthen Petrobras, the state-controlled oil company, shortly after hosting the COP30 climate summit in the Amazon city of Belém.
Flávio Bolsonaro promised to end illegal deforestation by 2029, but his programme barely mentioned climate change. Under his father, environmental enforcement collapsed and deforestation soared. Environmental groups feared a repeat, which would cause lasting damage to an Amazon that scientists warn is approaching a point of no return. Lula’s victory keeps that scenario off the table, but it will be up to environmental and Indigenous movements to hold him to his climate commitments.
Flight and fallout
Election day brought one more test. The Justice Ministry reported public transport failures in at least seven states, raising fears of a repeat of 2022, when highway police held up buses carrying voters in Lula’s Northeast strongholds. The Bolsonaro side was also concerned that heavy rains, flooding and outages in southern and southeastern states would prevent people getting to polling stations. At the request of both campaigns, a Supreme Court justice extended voting by two hours, although the order came too late for many polling stations. It was never established who was behind the transport problems.
On election night, Flávio Bolsonaro refused to accept the result and said he would ask the TSE to annul the election, blaming the longer voting hours even though under 35,000 votes were cast during extended opening times. The TSE confirmed the result and rejected his claim that PL monitors had been shut out of the count.
Flávio’s next move was to flee. On 26 October, a Supreme Court Justice banned him from travelling abroad and ordered him to surrender his passports as part of a money laundering investigation. The following night, he apparently slipped across the border into Argentina with his family, then flew by private jet, by way of Ecuador, to Miami. US Secretary of State Marco Rubio said President Donald Trump had personally cleared his entry.
His flight backfired at home, kicking off the contest to lead the right in 2030. The letter Flávio released from abroad, in which he called himself ‘the true president-elect’, brought criticism even from the PL’s president, and his campaign coordinator conceded there was no evidence of fraud. Tarcísio, re-elected governor in the first round, had advised him not to leave. A poll found 52 per cent of Brazilians thought he was wrong to go, while 46 per cent approved, a sign of how divided people are.
Ultimately, the PL and the rest of the right-wing camp recognised the result and urged supporters not to protest. This presented a strong contrast with 2022, when Jair Bolsonaro supporters blocked roads and camped outside army barracks for weeks. This time, it was the UNE that took to the streets, in at least 17 cities, to reject fraud claims and celebrate the result.
Legal challenges are running out of steam. Of the dozens of complaints before the TSE, the court has agreed to examine one from the New Party, which accuses Lula of using a social welfare programme for electoral advantage, but nothing has emerged that could justify overturning the result. Some complaints highlight the participation of social movements and trade union federations in Lula’s campaign, aiming to make civil society’s role in the election a contentious matter.
A hard road ahead
Lula’s fourth and final term begins on 5 January 2027, and he’ll face a Congress even further to the right than the current one. The PL’s 121 Chamber of Deputies seats and 28 Senate seats will make it the biggest force in both chambers. According to projections, Lula can consistently count on only 124 deputies and 16 senators, while 143 deputies and 34 senators will oppose him. The rest will cast the decisive votes on a case-by-case basis.
The first test comes in February 2027 when Congress elects its leaders. The PT has joined a bloc of 14 other parties backing the re-election of Hugo Motta of the centrist Republicanos as Chamber president, but the Senate race is tighter, and several newly elected senators campaigned on promises to impeach Supreme Court justices. A working majority will come at a price. Lula is preparing to give more ministries to the Centrão, a group of parties that back whichever government is in power in exchange for funds and posts, while there’s little financial room to manoeuvre. Much of the social agenda students marched for, and the climate and environmental protections civil society is demanding, will depend on deals with an agribusiness-friendly majority and parties that backed Flávio Bolsonaro.
Lula will also spend at least two years dealing with a US president who has openly sided with his opponents. Relations thawed in late 2025, but US tariffs had already hit Brazilian exports, and the Brazilian Intelligence Agency warned before the vote that US actions towards Brazil had intensified. Afterwards, Trump said the election looked ‘rigged’ but offered no evidence. His fraud claim and the shelter he’s given Flávio Bolsonaro will allow the far right to organise against the government from US soil. Still, Trump went on to say he gets on well with Lula and hasn’t granted Flávio Bolsonaro asylum. The Democrats’ gains in the 3 November midterms may also limit how far he can go.
In his first national address following the election, Lula thanked those who took to ‘the streets and social media’ to defend their rights and said popular mobilisation would shape his government. Street and online pressure pushed Congress to approve the end of the six-day working week. Election integrity, under pressure from social media algorithms and foreign interference, held largely because people turned out to defend democratic institutions.
The students who filled the streets in October have made clear that’s where they intend to stay. Their mobilisation, and that of the wider civil society that carried Lula to victory, will be needed to hold his government to its promises on climate and inequality and stop any further assault on democracy.
OUR CALLS FOR ACTION
-
Flávio Bolsonaro and his allies must respect the election result and pursue any complaints strictly through legal channels.
-
The incoming government must protect the right of civil society to mobilise and take part in political life, and honour its commitments on climate and inequality.
-
The US government must respect the outcome of Brazil’s election and abstain from interfering in Brazil’s domestic politics and judicial processes.
Cover photo by Mauro Pimentel/AFP.


